Organic food is not healthier, study finds

08/11-10 kl. 10:55 Research / Life Science

Photo: Photos.com When it comes to health benefits, organically grown carrots do not have the edge after all, a new study shows

Organic vegetables do not contain more healthy antioxidants or minerals than those grown the conventional way

by Luci Ellis

If you think paying a higher price for organic vegetables gives your diet a health boost, think again.

Antioxidant levels in organic onions, carrots and potatoes are no different to their conventionally-grown counterparts, a new study shows.

This is according to science news site Sciencedaily.com.

The results were released last week in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry.

Same antioxidant levels

The study was carried out by OrgTrace, which is cooperation between researchers at the University of Copenhagen’s Faculty of Life Sciences, Denmark’s Technical University and Århus University.

In the study, Pia Knuthsen and colleagues conclude that the health benefits of organic food are not scientifically documented.

The scientists carried out experiments in which they analyzed levels of antioxidants termed ‘polyphenols’ in organic and conventionally-grown onions, carrots and potatoes.

They found no differences in polyphenol content between organic and traditional methods of growth.

»On the basis of the present study carried out under well controlled conditions, it cannot be concluded that organically grown onions, carrots, and potatoes generally have higher contents of health-promoting secondary metabolites in comparison with the conventionally cultivated ones,« the report states.

Not necessarily a rip-off

Previous studies into the health benefits of organic vegetables have failed to take differences in geography, climate and cultivation methods into account, say the researchers.

This report takes these differences into account, and as a result, organic vegetables’ health benefits disappear.

However, this doesn’t mean that organic food in general is a waste of money, the researchers point out.

Aside from potential health benefits, consumers choose to buy organic products because of animal welfare issues, environmental benefits and better taste.

luci@adm.ku.dk

Stay in the know about news and events happening in Copenhagen by signing up for the University Post’s weekly newsletter here.

Do you buy organic food?

2 comments

Write a comment

09/11-10 kl. 14:44 nobody:

The point of organic food...

The point of organic food is not that it has more nutrients but that it was cultivated/grown without any hormones, livestock antibiotics, chemical pesticides etc.

Cheers,
nobody

14/12-10 kl. 13:07 someone else:

Agreed!

@nobody: Indeed! If organic food is healthier than non-organic food in any way, it'd be because of the lack of residual pesticides etc. But it's narrow-minded to just think about the nutritional values of the carrot you're crunching away on. It's about sustainability in a much broader sense. Do something good for our planet and buy organic whenever you can! BTW, nothing against the study - it's research, which, by definition, is narrow-minded (has to be)!
'sup!

21/05-12 kl. 06:00 Campus

Innovator: Don’t be afraid to fail

In 2011, Gregory and two friends started the ‘Copenhagen Union’. Deliberately unambitious at the start, the initiative now trains students and organizes high-profile debates

See also:: The experts: How to make your own job; Crisis, what crisis? More student start-ups

20/05-12 kl. 06:00 Culture

The experts: How to make your own job

Entrepreneurship is a field filled with myths: One of them is that it is hard to start up something on your own. The experts have offered to share their tips