Non-Danes kicked out of mentor group

14/02-12 kl. 12:19 Campus / Humanities
Mentor group with no internationals Photo: Patricia Trincado Only Danes here. Mentor Day 2 February, just after the 'Danes-only' injunction

International mentors for incoming students have been expelled from the Faculty of Humanities mentor group. Non-Danes don’t understand the Danish system, say organisers

by Patricia Trincado

For three semesters now, international students have, together with Danes, been mentors of exchange students at the Faculty of Humanities.

International mentors proved to be good mentors as they already had experienced the same coming-to-Denmark situation.

But now, the Faculty of Humanities has got rid of all non-Danish mentors. Danes are more appropriate for the task due to their knowledge of Denmark and, therefore, they can integrate better the newcomers, the Faculty argues.

Danes know Denmark

In an e-mail from the Study and Career Guidance Centre at the Faculty of Humanities, international mentors are rebuffed with an ambiguous underhand compliment to their hard work.

»…Being an international mentor has proven to be a lot harder than being a Danish mentor, and the time and effort the international students have put in to planning activities has been great considering that this is volunteer work,« they write.

However, »Danish mentors typically have a better idea of how the Danish system works (both within the University and the city/country), and this knowledge is important when planning events for the mentees«.

International loneliness

Helle Rod Søgaard, international coordinator at the Faculty of Humanities, elaborates in an e-mail exchange with the University Post that international mentors have ‘great value’. But international students need something else, she says.

»The main purpose of the mentor programme is to help international students to function in Danish society and culture and at university in particular. International students themselves have requested more contact with Danish students in order to integrate better into student life at The Faculty of Humanities.«

The Faculty points to new research showing that international students are at risk of feeling lonely and leaving before they initially intended.

Faculty: Foreign students expect Danish mentors

The mentor programme should prevent this loneliness.

»We have had to act on this and set up our mentor programme accordingly,« says Helle Rod Søgaard.

»Our experience shows that international students expect that their assigned mentor is Danish and has thorough knowledge about Denmark, Danish culture and the Danish educational system«, she adds.

International student initiative to be mentors

It was originally international students’ themselves that suggested back in 2010 to let international full degree students be mentors of newcomer international students.

International mentors considered themselves to be good for the mentor group, as they added an international perspective.

Internationals consider themselves more to what the new students have to go through when they come to Denmark. They have already experienced what is like to be a new student at the University of Copenhagen, so they know exactly which are the main needs and questions when the new students arrive to the city.

Job is to integrate with Danes

Mauro Castaño is one of the mentors who has been kicked off the team. He says that international mentors have more empathy. Since they have been in the same situation once, they really want to help others adapt easier: »They know things that newcomers should be interested to know, as well as sharing the feeling and experience of being new in a different country and culture«, says Mauro.

But Mauro’s arguments are not being heard. Helle from the Faculty doesn’t buy them.

»We are very aware that international mentors can offer new international students something else that Danish mentors can’t. But our consideration with the mentor programme is to facilitate integration with Danish students as well as Danish society«.

Read an article in which Colombian student Mauro argues against the decision here.

universitypost@adm.ku.dk

Stay in the know about news and events happening in Copenhagen by signing up for the University Post’s weekly newsletter here.

Should mentors for new incoming students only be Danes?

3 comments

Write a comment

09/03-12 kl. 14:29 Elisabete :

The reasons behind the decision of graduate students and other highly qualified individuals (including those hired in high positions in Denmark) to leave Denmark runs on deeper waters. It is a deep structural problem in the Danish society, from how you are treated by state officers to just try and live in Denmark to the general feeling of disinterest of Danish people in non-Danes and their experiences and opinions once they actually have to listen to them; not to mention the difficulties to compete on fair grounds with (white) Danes in the job market. I guess this is a classic example of how a non-Danish experience and voice means nothing in this pathetic integration/assimilation parody made in Denmark. One of the reasons why I left Denmark.

16/02-12 kl. 02:22 Gijs Stevers:

My background: Recently graduated international master student who has been a mentor to exchange students for 2 years.

After reading the articles I could perfectly understand the reasoning behind both letting international students become mentors to exchange students (as suggested by Mauro) or sticking to Danes only (new policy by Helle). Giving it second thought though, I favor Mauro's view combined with a change in the current system.

Letting international full-degree students become mentors combines internationals which are proud of Denmark with Danes which are open to share experiences with internationals. In this environments I think the best friendships (and integration) are created.

One of the arguments Helle uses comes from the governments (and universities) aim to have more international talent stay in Denmark (after graduation). This is mainly targeted towards master students (as 95% of exchange students return home after their exchange). Keeping international full-degree students away from open minded Danes in a mentor network for exchange students works very counterproductive to reach this particular goal.

Whether it is best for an exchange student to have an international or Danish mentor I do not know... From a practical perspective an international student will be better equipped to kickstart the Copenhagen and University life of an exchange student as he/she knows exactly what the exchange student is going through. From a cultural perspective I think it would be much greater to have a Danish mentor as meeting Danes (and other nationalities) is one of the reasons to go on exchange.

What I do know... is that I did not get a mentor as an international full-degree student. For students like me I think it would be even more valuable to have a Danish mentor helping you adapting to Denmark as you actually want to start living a similar life as your mentor (in contradiction to the ''exchange student life''). Almost all full-degree internationals have a desire to learn the Danish language, get a Danish job, and drink beer with the Danes.

In conclusion, considering U-CPH is aiming for integration of internationals and keeping foreign talent in Denmark my suggestion to Helle is:
- Let international full-degree students be mentors to exchange students along with the Danes!
- Consider an (all Danish) mentor network for newly arrived full-degree internationals!

Best,
Gijs

14/02-12 kl. 21:40 Sorin:

So, let me get this straight. There are too many people that want to be mentors, right? Well, why not make a team (1 Dane + 1 international) for each new international student. It's not that you have to pay them extra, they are volunteers.

Join the debate read rules for debate here.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
gregoryrockson
21/05-12 kl. 06:00 Campus

Innovator: Don’t be afraid to fail

In 2011, Gregory and two friends started the ‘Copenhagen Union’. Deliberately unambitious at the start, the initiative now trains students and organizes high-profile debates

See also:
The experts: How to make your own job
Crisis, what crisis? More student start-ups
raftillustration
20/05-12 kl. 06:00 Culture

The experts: How to make your own job

Entrepreneurship is a field filled with myths: One of them is that it is hard to start up something on your own. The experts have offered to share their tips

See also:
Crisis, what crisis? More student start-ups
studentstartups
19/05-12 kl. 06:00 Education

Crisis, what crisis? More student start-ups

Data shows that students are using the recession as an opportunity. More are starting businesses

spoiltstudent
18/05-12 kl. 10:00 Politics

Danish business: Students are spoilt rotten

We are dirt poor, claims Danish Student Council. Nonsense, says Chamber of Commerce, that calls for a halt to excessive student ‘salaries’

See also:
Only money for cheap champagne
cheapchampagne
18/05-12 kl. 08:00 Politics

Only money for cheap champagne

There is still a lot to fight for, maintain activists, as they celebrated 100 years of the students’ union

See also:
Danish business: Students are spoilt rotten
SpringTipGuysguide1
17/05-12 kl. 08:30 Culture

Top 10: Spring tips for guys

Guys: Springtime isn't just for the ladies. The University Post has put some things together to keep you occupied for the next couple of months

See also:
Top 10: Spring tips for guys, part 2
Top 10: Spring tips for girls
Top 10: Spring tips for girls, part 2

Facts

The Mentor Group
is a group of students that help new international students get a good and easy start at the University of Copenhagen.

Each international student has the option to become assigned to a 'personal' mentor to help with practicalities in connection with the arrival and during the stay.

Furthermore, the Mentor Group arranges a whole variety of activities, excursions and parties each semester.

The Mentor Group is organised on a completely voluntary basis. Most activities are free of charge.


Subscribe to newsletter

See pictures of plant fascination day at uni

Strange succulents, tiny seedlings and plant pests (under the microscope). All laid out in the greenhouses

Are Danish students spoilt?

Photo Competition: Show us your room

Send us a photo of your room and win tickets to the NorthSide Festival


Kontakt redaktionen

Write us an e-mail: uni-avis@adm.ku.dk

University of Copenhagen
Nørregade 10
1165 Copenhagen K
Denmark
Tel. +45 35 32 28 98

Copyright 2009 © Universitetsavisen.ku.dk