29/6-12 10:10

Judgement: Penkowa guilty of scientific misconduct

Milena Penkowa4
Photo: Lars Juul Hauschildt
New judgement in the Milena Penkowa case finds Penkowa guilty of scientific misconduct
The Danish Committees on Scientific Misconduct have put forth their assessment of the first two Milena Penkowa cases. Their judgement is clear - Penkowa is found guilty of using false and misleading data, reports Weekendsavisen today

Milena Penkowa has been found guilty of a »serious breach of good scientific conduct« concluded The Danish Committees on Scientific Misconduct (DCSD) after an examination of the first two Penkowa cases, writes Danish newspaper Weekendsavisen today.

This judgement comes after UCPH reported Milena Penkowa to the DCSD last year, after finding out that she was involved in the biggest scientific fraud in the university's history. If you missed out on the story, get a recap here.

Milena Penkowa has until the start of August to comment on the draft judgement of the DCSD before it becomes official. However it is highly unlikely that her comments will have an effect, writes Weekendavisen, because she has already presented many self-justifications and accusations since the start of the scandal without much impact.

False data

The committee from DSCD has judged Penkowa over two cases. The first regarding a published article in 'Experimental Neurology' from 2002 and the second an article submitted to the 'Journal of Clinical Oncology' from 2010.

The committee consisting of doctors, scientists and High Court Judge Henrik Gunst, has concluded that Penkowa has given »misleading and false information« about the scientific methods she has used, has »constructed data« and »acted intentionally«, reports the weekly newspaper.

According to Weekendavisen, this judgement would have cost Penkowa her university position, had she not already been dismissed.

No comments

This is the first examination and judgement by the DSCD. In August 2012 the committee will present the results of two other examinations from the Penkowa case. Also in August, an international committee will present their results after a close examination of Penkowa's scientific research.

Currently the Danish police are looking into the Penkowa case to find out whether it is possible to raise legal sanctions based on the judgements by DSCD. Penkowa already received three months probation for her fraud actions earlier in the saga.

Neither Milena Penkowa nor the University of Copenhagen has made a public comment on the findings. UCPH refused comment to our sister newspaper Uniavisen as they believe parts of the case are still classified as private.

polina.chebotareva@adm.ku.dk

Stay in the know about news and events happening in Copenhagen by signing up for the University Post’s weekly newsletter here.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2> <blockquote> <cite>
  • You may insert videos with [video:URL]
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
Social KUA
It is to be more than just airport pickups and translations of Danish phrases. It is the Faculty of Humanities' new mentor scheme called the 'QA Programme'
immigrantkids

Do you know how to use a computer? Of course you do. A former student of the University of Copenhagen is organising a computers project for young immigrants who have bleak prospects

Culture 15/5-13 20:27

Knowing yourself to know others

moon9
A small splotch on the world map, Denmark must navigate foreign cultures. The take-home message from a forum for ambassadors, VIPs: 'Bridging cultures'
Science 15/5-13 14:09

Insects: The food of the future

deliciousInsects2
Bugs reduce pollution, increase nutrition, and should seriously be considered as a food source: This is according to a UN report with University of Copenhagen contribitions
Co-authorship

Scientists need to publish to get research grants - and established scientists are demanding to be cited as co-authors on younger scientists' work. Experts say it's time for more rules

Politics 14/5-13 13:01

PhD student stood up to top scientist

AnnemetteNielsen
PhD student Annemette Nielsen refused to credit a top scientist and two members of his team as co-authors on her PhD dissertation. She thereby broke an unspoken rule
Science 13/5-13 6:22 1

Could you simply not eat for a day?

LLFasting
LAB AND LIBRARY: In this first instalment of our new science & research feature, Martin Borch Jensen writes in to tell us about how eating every second day could extend his life
dentalGold
Reserves of gold, used for dentures, is missing from the dentists' school, the Department of Odontology. An external audit proves that no one has been taking stock of the precious metal

Contact University Post

Write us an email: universitypost@adm.ku.dk

Or call the newsroom on +45 35 32 28 98
(Monday - Thursday 9.00 - 16.00)

University of Copenhagen

  • Nørregade 10
  • 1165 Copenhagen K
  • Denmark
  • Tel. +45 35 32 28 98
Write us an email: uni-avis@adm.ku.dk