Erasmus grants are not fair

05/11-10 kl. 07:00 Politics
Erasmus grants Photo: Carmela Jasmin Herbst She may be smiling, but for Dutch Erasmus student Kim Teo, a visit to the cash machine can be a sobering experience

While some students can save up, others are forced to live in poverty

by Maya Lievegoed

The Erasmus programme is dealing out grants unfairly. This is according to students who feel cheated by a complicated system that rewards students from some regions while penalizing others, apparently at random.

The Erasmus exchange programme offers European exchange students grants which are intended to offset the extra costs that arise from studying abroad.

But questions to a sample of international students by the University Post reveal large differences: While some Eastern European students claim around EUR 500, a German student has to make do with a miserly EUR 100.

Grants used for summer holiday

Many international students receive a mishmash of grants from their university, the Erasmus programme, and besides that, a top-up by a national grant.

According to the EU Commission’s Directorate General for Education and Culture, students from a country with a lower standard of living get a higher grant going to a country with a high standard of living.

But students say that the system is unfair.

»I pay twice as much for my room here in Denmark, compared to my friend who went to Poland. But I receive just ten euro more from the programme than she does,« says Dutch Erasmus student Kim Teo.

Read the European Commission's defense of differences in Erasmus grants here.

While Kim borrows money from the bank to make ends meet, her friend in Poland is now saving money for summer.

Germans get next to nothing

»Erasmus grants should be EUR 250 on average EU-wide,« says Natascha Sander, Information & Communication officer, stating European Commission policy in response to a University Post query.

But even our cursory query among students shows that some receive considerably less, others considerably more.

And even within nations there are differences. Aitor Veiga from the northern Basque city of Pamplona gets EUR 420 a month, while Veronica Martinez Vidal from the Spanish capital Madrid feels the pinch with just EUR 150.

»I think this is not fair because we are all university students from the same country and we should have the same rights and opportunities,« reacts Veronica.

Overall, it is best to come from Poland, with a monthly grant that is sometimes as high as EUR 550 a month. Worst is to come from Germany, whose students sometimes have to settle for only EUR 100, according to our sample.

Who gets what? See the full results of the University Post's mini-survey here.

uni-avis@adm.ku.dk

Stay in the know about news and events happening in Copenhagen by signing up for the University Post’s weekly newsletter here .

Do you think that differences to Erasmus grants are fair?

4 comments

Write a comment

14/11-10 kl. 06:14 Anonymous:

The Erasmus grants shouldn't reflect which country you come from but which country/city you are going to and the cost of living in that city. It's a bizzare concept that students because of the country/uni they are from get 500 EUR even if the choose to go to a city where the cost of living is dirt cheap!

08/11-10 kl. 01:30 student from poland:

Last year I was in Spain, and I've got 275 EUR monthly. My friends from German 570 EUR.
Is not depend only from country, but from University (in my city 3 different Universities sent for Erazmus and the differences between grands was around 150 EUR).
Moreover, for my parents giving me additional money in EUR was much more harder first of all cause our salaries aren't so hight like in west European countries, and because of changing with currency - EUR was between 3,2-5,0 Polish Zlotys - so differences each month was quite big for them.

12/11-10 kl. 00:25 Anonymous:

Whatevs, guys. Non-EU nations, like the US and Australia, don't get paid anything to study abroad. Everything comes straight out of the students' pocket. Everything. That is, unless you are able to find yourself a scholarship somewhere. But no free Erasmus-type money for us.

31/12-11 kl. 19:27 achraf:

true. !! yeh that's really unfai i mean there is no funding for us -_- not only when dealing with exchanges, but tuition fees are so damn high ! WTH and then you get nothing! 14000 € or more a year ? Ar you fuckin kiddin me?

Join the debate read rules for debate here.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
SpringTipGuysguide1
17/05-12 kl. 08:30 Culture

Top 10: Spring tips for guys

Guys: Springtime isn't just for the ladies. The University Post has put some things together to keep you occupied for the next couple of months

See also:
Top 10: Spring tips for guys, part 2
Top 10: Spring tips for girls
Top 10: Spring tips for girls, part 2
lostgraphicteaser
16/05-12 kl. 10:11 Education

Lost generation may find their way yet

A generation of university graduates wonders how they are ever going to get a job that matches their qualifications. But according to new European statistics, there is hope

See also:
Graphic: Where are the jobs in Europe?
soupeaters
15/05-12 kl. 13:00 Culture

This Sunday: Piano virtuoso to play John Cage

Artistic event to feature mushrooms, silence, and music. Special guest is virtuoso pianist Rolf Hind who will play avant garde master John Cage. Free entrance for everyone

UCPHsecondworldwar
15/05-12 kl. 07:55 Research / Humanities

Historians debate Copenhagen links to Nazis

University of Copenhagen scientists kept co-operating with Nazified German scientists during the 1930's, and the official University upheld a co-operation policy with the Nazis from 1940. Recent conference sheds light on a murky period in Danish history

Orhan Pamuk
15/05-12 kl. 06:17 Culture

Turkish writer Orhan Pamuk gets Sonning prize

Prestigious cultural award goes to a man who has 'challenged cultural boundaries', says jury

Liferevy_1
14/05-12 kl. 12:34 Campus / Life Science

See photos from the Life Sciences revue

The revue spirit is spreading throughout the university. Our photographer visited the former Faculty of Life Sciences over the weekend as the students got on stage to mock university life

See also:
Gallery: Life revue '12
Gallery: Physics Revue '12

Subscribe to newsletter

Guide to Denmark's summer festivals 2012

Summer is right around the corner and so are the many festivals that sweeten this time of year. The University Post brings you 10 festivals worth looking forward to while you finish off the semester’s last exams

Photo Competition: Show us your room

Send us a photo of your room and win tickets to the NorthSide Festival


Kontakt redaktionen

Write us an e-mail: uni-avis@adm.ku.dk

University of Copenhagen
Nørregade 10
1165 Copenhagen K
Denmark
Tel. +45 35 32 28 98

Copyright 2009 © Universitetsavisen.ku.dk