Comment: Is it better to pay for your education?

27/04-11 kl. 08:05 Debate
Sara_NYU Photo: Sara Sjölin Sara in front of the iconic Washington Square Arch surrounded by NYU buildings

Danish Sara Sjölin is studying Economics and Journalism at New York University. Originally sceptical about the high tuition fees, she now wonders if the American system is better than the Danish one

by Sara Sjölin

When I first came to New York University (NYU) last summer to do my Master's I was certain that I would disapprove of the American educational system with its ridiculously high tuition fees.

But after spending almost eight months and a lot of money on NYU, I have observed several benefits of actually having to pay for your education.

First of all, I have experienced a completely different level of motivated students: No one skips classes, everyone reads all of the study material and in general there is a consensus that school comes first.

After all, it makes sense that when you spend more than DKK 100,000 per semester on schooling you want to get your money's worth and not spend hours hanging out with friends or getting drunk on Thursdays, like most Danish students who take their free education for granted.

Paying for quality

Another huge benefit of studying at a private university like NYU is the quality of the lectures and the general facilities. We are only 12 people in my program and the individual attention we get is sometimes almost too much.

We have our own internship advisor, a journalism teacher that was made the subject of a movie, and an accounting professor who writes books for the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

The general facilities are world class which makes it so much easier to be a student. For example, most of my lectures are videotaped and if I write an email to any office at the university they get back to me within hours. In general, the service level is impeccable and everything works.

Creating inequality

But of course the extra service level and high quality lectures have a downside. The tuition fee is extremely high and it prevents lower income students to attend certain universities. The ones who do end up with student loans well over US$ 100,000.

The free Danish educational system gives everyone an equal chance of getting a university degree, regardless of their parents' income. Students tend to be less competitive and the result is that students help each other out, learn how to work in groups and dare to think creatively.

So, even though I have learned to appreciate the privileges of NYU granted by its high tuition, I would be terrified if Denmark copied the American system. But it needs to be recognized that Denmark is not perfect and that there actually are advantages if students pay for their university education.

Read Sara's blog on Danish newspaper Berlingske Tidende (in Danish)

Should all University of Copenhagen students pay tuition fees?

3 comments

Write a comment

16/08-11 kl. 18:57 Eva:

During my time in Denmark as an American, I met many nice people who based their knowledge of American practices on media and hype. Please don't give the impression that all poor people in the U.S. are deprived of going to expensive universities because of their lack of money, or that most rack up debts of $100,000. That is simply not true. Look up http://studentaid.ed.gov/PORTALSWebApp/students/english/index.jsp and do your own research. They are responsible for federal student loans and grants.
My first year of college was at a very expensive private university (University of Redlands). I qualified for student grants and loans and paid less than $3,000 out of the $14,000 yearly tuition fee ( a lot of money in 1990). The rest was paid for by grants. At the time, just more than 70% of the student population were on financial aid of this sort. After my first year, I transferred to another university (University of California, Santa Cruz) that had more options for my major. This is a public university where I qualified for full financial aid and did not have to pay ANYTHING for tuition. The only loans that I received was to cover the cost of housing. I could spend that anywhere I wanted to or choose to not accept it. I also received $500 per quarter in grants to purchase books.

Tuition for students from other countries or states is another matter. All Americans can apply for financial aid, however foreign students can not. Tuition is higher for both.

Graduate students in certain fields are the ones who rack up the most debt. They do qualify for financial aid as well, however they need to work more to find grants that apply to them. The amount of debt they rack up depends on their field, length of study, and of course, university.

Planning for college is something that many Americans start to do early. We work hard to get into college and that includes researching the best schools for the individual and figuring out how to pay for it. The types of funding available include federally subsidized student loans, federal grants, scholarships, and private loans. There are many ways to fund your college experience. As someone who has been through the system, it is frustrating to encounter people who say they can't afford to go to college. Usually these people don't know what their options are or they don't really want to put the work into securing the funding. The mentality that they can't afford to go is a barrier for their social mobility.

Yes, college is getting more expensive in the U.S., but it is not unattainable. You just have to work hard for it and even then, you may not get into the college of your choice because getting into your college of choice can be a big competition, unless it is a junior college (anyone can get in). That's just part of life. You don't always get what you thought you wanted, but you might end up with something just as good or better.

02/05-11 kl. 12:47 Hamid:

Taking into consideration the large amount of tuition fees for overseas students at Danish Universities, apart from the considerable cost of living in COPENHAGEN, it would be prevent them from studying here.

In my view, all students should be consider as equal right to have free education University whatever their nationality.

For instance, I have been admitted to the excellent MSc programes at the COPENHAGEN UNIVERSITY for 2011, but i could not accept my offers of admission because of financial situation even though, i would like to study in DENMARK since i was seventeen!

While the Admission Committee has assist the application forms according to the admission criteria , they will select those applicants with slight interest toward their education, so in the most cases, students will do best at the university, although the tuition fee is free (For EU/EEA students).

27/04-11 kl. 10:01 Paula:

Coming from a paid university system, I think that all the benefits (quality criteria) that you are indicating would be resolved if the academic demands at Danish Universities were higher.

Having American friends, I can tell that their commitment is related to how difficult it is to be accepted at any university, and to the high academic standards to which they are subjected.

Money is more a problem than an stimulus when you parents can not afford the fees. In that sense, the Danish higher educational system seems to me the best way of educating every adult that wants to study. So maybe what Danish universities should do is try to get the best from their students.

Join the debate read rules for debate here.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.
SpringTipGuysguide1
17/05-12 kl. 08:30 Culture

Top 10: Spring tips for guys

Guys: Springtime isn't just for the ladies. The University Post has put some things together to keep you occupied for the next couple of months

See also:
Top 10: Spring tips for guys, part 2
Top 10: Spring tips for girls
Top 10: Spring tips for girls, part 2
lostgraphicteaser
16/05-12 kl. 10:11 Education

Lost generation may find their way yet

A generation of university graduates wonders how they are ever going to get a job that matches their qualifications. But according to new European statistics, there is hope

See also:
Graphic: Where are the jobs in Europe?
soupeaters
15/05-12 kl. 13:00 Culture

This Sunday: Piano virtuoso to play John Cage

Artistic event to feature mushrooms, silence, and music. Special guest is virtuoso pianist Rolf Hind who will play avant garde master John Cage. Free entrance for everyone

UCPHsecondworldwar
15/05-12 kl. 07:55 Research / Humanities

Historians debate Copenhagen links to Nazis

University of Copenhagen scientists kept co-operating with Nazified German scientists during the 1930's, and the official University upheld a co-operation policy with the Nazis from 1940. Recent conference sheds light on a murky period in Danish history

Orhan Pamuk
15/05-12 kl. 06:17 Culture

Turkish writer Orhan Pamuk gets Sonning prize

Prestigious cultural award goes to a man who has 'challenged cultural boundaries', says jury

Liferevy_1
14/05-12 kl. 12:34 Campus / Life Science

See photos from the Life Sciences revue

The revue spirit is spreading throughout the university. Our photographer visited the former Faculty of Life Sciences over the weekend as the students got on stage to mock university life

See also:
Gallery: Life revue '12
Gallery: Physics Revue '12

Subscribe to newsletter

Guide to Denmark's summer festivals 2012

Summer is right around the corner and so are the many festivals that sweeten this time of year. The University Post brings you 10 festivals worth looking forward to while you finish off the semester’s last exams

Photo Competition: Show us your room

Send us a photo of your room and win tickets to the NorthSide Festival


Kontakt redaktionen

Write us an e-mail: uni-avis@adm.ku.dk

University of Copenhagen
Nørregade 10
1165 Copenhagen K
Denmark
Tel. +45 35 32 28 98

Copyright 2009 © Universitetsavisen.ku.dk